Nice try

You can’t keep a devious tenant down. I read in one of my legal journals of a tenant who issued legal proceedings against his landlord and gave as the landlord address for service of the court paperwork, the building where his own flat was. When the landlord failed to respond to the proceedings (because, surprise surprise, he had not received them), the tenant obtained a ‘default judgment’ (which is a procedure for obtaining a court judgment on the basis that the defendant has not responded to the claim).

When the judgment was challenged (when the landlord finally found out about it), the tenant said that he was justified in giving the building where he lived as the landlords address, as the landlord went there to collect rent and it was therefore a ‘place of business’ within the meaning of the court rules. The Court of Appeal however did not agree. Letting a property, they said, was not capable of converting that property into a place of business, as the landlord only has limited power to enter it. The judgment was set aside.

For those interested, the case is O’Hara v. McDougal [2005].

No related posts.


Back to top

If you are a landlord, agent, advisor or tenant you will find more help and guidance on my main Landlord Law site. See also my online shop Your Law Store.

>> Follow this link to read our comments policy. If you have a landlord and tenant related problem please do not ask it here but use our >> Blog Clinic.

Comments close after three months.

Sorry, comments are closed for this post.




»

«
Recent posts:
Five ways for landlords to protect properties against fraudsters and criminals

Landlords need to be constantly vigilant as criminals are out there and targeting properties like y[more]

Is the landlord obliged to rehouse this tenant?

If a property is due to be demolished before the end of the fixed term, where does that leave the te[more]

How to interpret this confusing break clause?

Break clauses can be difficult to interpret and this is an example of a particularly confusing one. [more]

This week on School for Landlords I look at guarantee forms, when you should use them and how they w[more]

Can my tenants use the 3x deposits rule?

Here is a question to the blog clinic from Jay who is a landlord: Hi I protected the deposit within [more]

Landlord Law Blog roundup from 29 January

A big item of news this week was the launch of the Deposit Guard tenancy deposit scheme.  However a[more]

Can the landlord make a further deposit deduction?

Here is a question to the blog clinic from Andrew who is a tenant: I have, today, received an email [more]

Ben Reeve Lewis Friday Newsround #44

[In view of the snow, Ben Reeve Lewis has abandoned his Hawaiian shirt for a pair of slippers...[more]

How a landlord saved his tenant’s life

Sometimes it is good to check up on tenants - they may be in trouble and need help. [more]

Can a student be charged £100 for ending a tenancy early?

A student changes her mind after signing a tenancy agreement and agrees with the landlord that she w[more]