Sign up for my Weekly Tips on a Tuesday (and get a free guide)>> Click here

Discharge bonus – an alternative to deposits?

Could discharge bonus's be used instead of deposits?Discharge bonus v. tenancy deposit

There is an interesting post over on the Pain Smith blog which raises a new alternative to tenancy deposits.  A discharge bonus.

A discharge bonus is where the tenant pays no deposit (and so the landlord does not have to mess about with tedious tenancy deposit scheme administration) but if the tenant leaves the property in good order, the landlord will make a bonus payment.  A discharge bonus.  If the property is left in a mess, he won’t.

Court of Appeal authority

The authority for this suggestion comes from a recent Court of Appeal decision, UK Housing Alliance (North West) Ltd v Francis, which was about a sale and leaseback arrangement. To quote Pain Smith:

Mr Francis had sold his property to UK Housing and then taken a 10 year AST. He was paid a sum of £87,500 initially and would receive the remaining figure of £37,500 at the end of the 10 year term. If he breached the tenancy such that it was terminated by UK Housing then he would receive none of the final sum.

Mr Frances failed to pay his rent and possession proceedings were issued against him. He claimed however that he was nevertheless still entitled to the £37,000. One of his reasons was that this was a deposit within the meaning of the Housing Act.  The Court of Appeal however rejected this argument as, for it to be a deposit, it would have had to be money physically paid over by him to the landlord.  Which had not happened in his case, and (for this and other reasons) he lost his appeal.

But, suggest Pain Smith, we are left with a possible Court of Appeal authority for the discharge bonus.

Some practical issues

So does this mean that the offer a discharge bonus can now be used by landlords as a carrot to persuade tenants to pay their rent and leave the property nice and tidy?

Technically I suppose there is no reason why not.  But I can see a few problems:

  • As it is an ‘all or nothing’ situation, it will be unfair on tenants who leave the property in a good condition but fall down on just one or two minor issues
  • As the landlord will be paying it out of his own funds, there will be a temptation for him to find fault with the property at the end of the tenancy, so as to avoid paying the bonus
  • Tenants may suspect that the landlord will be doing this any and may thus have little incentive to look after the property, believing that the bonus will not be paid.  Particularly as the bonus will be just that, a bonus, and not the return of their own money
  • If the tenants anticipate the bonus by failing to pay their last months rent, the landlord will not have any deposit to offset this against.

I can also see hotly contested arguments about whether the bonus should or should not be paid.  The relevant tenancy agreement clauses would have to be carefully drafted.  In order to comply with the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations, I suspect that the final decision would have to be left to someone independent, like an inventory clerk.  If the decision was wholly down to the landlord the clause would be vulnerable to being found unfair under the regulations.

What do you think?  Do you think it is a good idea or do you think the disadvantages outweigh the apparent advantages?  Does anyone have any experience of this being used?



Buffer

Important note. If you are reading an old post, remember that the law may have changed since it was written.




Landlord LawAre you a letting agent or property manager?


Its a risky business if you don’t properly understand the legal issues


Landlord Law>> Click here for some special & free services to help you


 From Landlord Law and Easy Law Training





If you have a landlord and tenant related question please do not ask it here but use our
>> Blog Clinic.

Comments close after three months. Please >> click here to read our comments policy

Page 1 of 11

3 Responses to Discharge bonus – an alternative to deposits?

  1. I agree with you Tessa, that Tenants will see this as a way of “pulling one over” on a Landlord. It might work better in cases where the rent is paid up front, but in the current age where tenants are becoming more savvy about deposit protection etc,hey are probably not going to take to paying a premium rent.




»

«

About the post author:

Tessa Shepperson

Tessa is a lawyer specialising in residential landlord and tenant law. She runs the Landlord Law website (now in its 12th year) and is a director of Easy Law Training Ltd and Your Law Store. Tessa also sits on the Property Redress Scheme Council. When not working she enjoys reading, cooking and messing around on the computer. You can also find her on Google



The Landlord Law Blog from Tessa Shepperson

Tessa is an English lawyer specialising in residential landlord and tenant law.


Legal Services

Legal services are provided via Tessa's online service Landlord Law. Some advice services are provided by Tessa, other legal services are provided by specialist housing firm Anthony Gold.


Disclaimer

The purpose of this blog is to provide information, comment and discussion. Although Tessa, or guest bloggers, may from time to time, give helpful comments to readers' questions, these can only be based on the information given by the reader in his or her comment, which may not contain all material facts. Any comments or suggestions provided by Tessa or any guest bloggers should not therefore be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice from a qualified lawyer regarding any actual legal issue or dispute.


Nothing on this website should be construed as legal advice or perceived as creating a solicitor-client relationship (apart from the Fast Track block clinic service - so far as the questioners only are concerned).


Guest bloggers

Please note that any opinion expressed by a guest blogger is his or hers alone, and does not necessarily reflect the views of Tessa Shepperson, or the other writers on this blog.


Other websites from Tessa

Lodger Landlord | Google+ | Your Law Store | Google | Landlord Law facebook page | How to Evict Your Tenant website | the Which Tenancy Agreement Guide | Landlords Tips | Tenants Tips | Working on the Web | Landlord Law Store