To sign up for the Landlord Law Newsletter (and get a free guide)>> Click Here

Tag Archives: letting agents

Are these letting agents liable to the landlord for loss of rent where they are in breach of contract?

HousesHere is a question to the blog clinic from Brian who is a landlord:

We have had 2 properties under management by an agent since August 2012, referred to as 108 & and 96.

Our complaint concerns both properties. We pay 15% + VAT management fee, including rent loss cover.

On 16th April 2013 we discovered that no rents for either property had been banked with us since 24th July 2012. The agents were e-mailed immediately. In the e-mail reply on the 19th April a staff member explained that all the rents had been paid back into the account of the tenant in 108.

We warned the agent on 19th April that although they had repaid us, their error had endangered the 108 tenancy and that we would expect redress in this event.

Unable to afford repaying the agents, the108 tenant left without notice at the end of June 2013.

Despite numerous viewings by the agent the property remains untenanted. It was discovered that the agents had not inspected or cleaned after the tenant left.

We visited the agent’s office outlining our dissatisfactions with the standards of management and the costs we had incurred i.e. lost rentals, utilities, council tax and a 15% management fee paid where no apparent management had taken place. We were told that senior management was absent and not expected back in the office.

A week later an e-mail from a member of staff rejected our request for redress asserting that the blame lies between the tenant and the landlord, the agent refusing to accept responsibility for its shortcomings.

We wrote to the agent’s CEO To date we have had no reply. The 96 tenant is unwaged and receives housing benefit.

Do we have redress for:

1. misdirection of rents?
2. Loss of tenancy & rental & payment of council tax?
3. Mis-selling of rent protection for unwaged tenant?

You also mention in your email that you live overseas.

First off, I am a bit surprised that you did not detect that the rent had been paid to you by the agents between July 2012 and April 2013. It is generally a good idea to try to keep on top of these things.

If you had got wise to this situation in, say, August, and notified the agents, the problems would have been less.  This may affect any award that might be made to you in any compensation claim.

However there is no doubt that these agents have not acted in your best interests and if I were you I would be looking around to appoint another letting agent in their place.

Lets have a look at your question. You ask if you have a claim in respect of the following items:

1. Misdirection of rents.

If the agents received the rent from the tenant and then paid it back to the tenant rather than paying it over to you, then they are certainly liable for any losses you may have suffered in this regard.

However, it looks from your question as if the agents have actually paid you the rent.  In which case, as you have suffered no loss, you would not be entitled to any compensation.

2. Loss of tenancy

There are two elements to this.

  • The original tenant leaving early and
  • The failure to find a new one.

It is arguable that the tenant leaving early is down to them. However if a new tenant had been found promptly, this would not have been a problem.

It looks as if a possible reason for a new tenant not being found is the poor condition of the property.

We have not seen the terms of your agency agreement, but if this includes getting the property in a proper condition for re-letting, then the agents will be in breach of contract if they failed to do this.

I suspect the agents would be responsible for this – as you are living abroad it is not something you can do personally. That is presumably why you are using agents.

If a Judge in a claim were to find that they were in breach of their agreement with you here – what sort of award would he make?

The normal measure of damages for breach of contract cases is to put the claimant in the position he would have been in had the contract not been broken.

The Judge would also take into account the fact that they are your agents (and therefore owe you the greater duty of care that is imposed on agents under agency law) and that you are totally reliant on them as you live abroad.

So you would probably be awarded a percentage (probably a fairly high percentage) of the rent you would have got had they done what they should have done. The percentage would reflect the Judge’s view on their actual responsibility for the property remaining unlet.

3. Mis-selling of rent protection for unwaged tenant.

I assume from the question, that if this tenant fails to pay rent, you would not be able to claim under the rent protection policy as he is on benefit – this presumably being an exclusion under the terms of the policy.

If this is the case (and it would have to be checked) then if the tenant failed to pay rent, I think you probably would be entitled to claim against the agents – always assuming that they were aware that the tenant was on benefit at the time he signed the tenancy agreement.

They are the ones who found the tenant and should be aware of the terms of the rent guarantee policy they sold you.

However if the tenant lost his job and went on benefit after he moved into the property, then I don’t think the agents can be held responsible for this.

Unless maybe they failed to explain to you that the rent guarantee policy had this exception.

What to do next

FIrst of all, if you have not done this already, you should write a comprehensive letter to the agents setting out all your claims with details of their breaches of their agency agreement and your resultant losses.

If they fail to respond to this satisfactorily, you then need to check to see if they are a member of any redress scheme.  For example if they belong to the Property Ombudsman’s scheme, you can then refer your complaint to them.  The Property Ombudsman has the power to award compensation.

If the agents are not a member of any scheme, then you would need to bring a court claim.  As you live abroad, you would need solicitors for this.

In which case you should be careful to choose a firm which is experienced in housing / landlord & tenant work as this is a fairly esoteric area of law and not all firms handle it well.

Note that Anthony Gold, the solicitors associated with my Landlord Law service would be a good choice.

What do readers think about this case?


NB: Landlords who are having problems with their letting agents my be interested in my online guide on >> dismissing letting agents.

Ben Reeve Lewis Newsround #136

Ben on a chair

Ben Reeve Lewis’s Newsround is back with tales of eviction notices being handed to benefit tenants, Romanians and Bulgarians, and strange funding for CouncilsContinue Reading

Tenant caught in the middle of a landlord / agent dispute

houses

A tenant is being told different things by the landlord and the agent. What should she do? Can the agents evict her if the landlord wants her to stay?Continue Reading

Problems with unpaid rent after change of managing agent

flat

If a former agent fails to pay rent over which has been paid to him in error – what are the landlords rights? And can he also claim against the tenants?Continue Reading

Does a tenant HAVE to sign a new fixed term tenancy?

Section 21 notice

A tenant is told she cannot stay on under s periodic tenancy and must pay for advertising for new tenants if she leavesContinue Reading

My agents refunded the deposit to my tenants mid term

houses

These agents paid the deposit (and rent!) back to the tenants when the landlord decided to change agenciesContinue Reading

How to get rid of your letting agent – a new guide for landlords

Agency problems

I announce a new service on Landlord Law – a guide to help landlords who are having difficulties getting rid of their letting agents – particularly where the agents are in breach of their agency agreementContinue Reading



The Landlord Law Blog from Tessa Shepperson

Tessa is an English lawyer specialising in residential landlord and tenant law.


Legal Services

Legal services are provided via Tessa's online service Landlord Law. Some advice services are provided by Tessa, other legal services are provided by specialist housing firm Anthony Gold.


Disclaimer

The purpose of this blog is to provide information, comment and discussion. Although Tessa, or guest bloggers, may from time to time, give helpful comments to readers' questions, these can only be based on the information given by the reader in his or her comment, which may not contain all material facts. Any comments or suggestions provided by Tessa or any guest bloggers should not therefore be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice from a qualified lawyer regarding any actual legal issue or dispute.


Nothing on this website should be construed as legal advice or perceived as creating a solicitor-client relationship (apart from the Fast Track block clinic service - so far as the questioners only are concerned).


Guest bloggers

Please note that any opinion expressed by a guest blogger is his or hers alone, and does not necessarily reflect the views of Tessa Shepperson, or the other writers on this blog.


Other websites from Tessa

Lodger Landlord | School for Landlords | Google+ | Your Law Store | Google | Landlord Law facebook page | Tenancy Agreements Manual | How to Evict Your Tenant website | the Which Tenancy Agreement Guide | Landlords Tips | Tenants Tips