To sign up for the Landlord Law Newsletter (and get a free guide)>> Click Here

Tag Archives: Nuisance

Can tenants withhold rent because of noise from the upstairs flat?

Too much noiseHere is a question to the blog clinic from John who is a landlord

I am a landlord of converted house, there is a maisonette on the ground and first floor with single apartment on the top floor. I own both.

A new tenant moved into the apartment in September last year, she is a working professional and passed referencing with flying colours.

The tenants of the maisonette have complained repeatedly about noise from above, claiming that music is played until 4.00am and loud laughter and conversation keeps them awake every weekend.

I have spoken to the tenant of the apartment who admits that she sometimes has friends over at weekends but denies this is a frequent occurrence, she also said she would try to keep noise to a minimum.

The complaints have continued.

The tenants of the maisonette emailed me to demand the tenant is evicted and they will be withholding 8 days rent per month for each weekend they have to stay elsewhere in order to get a peaceful nights sleep.

I told them I disapproved of this and said the best solution is to have a civil conversation with the young lady, they told me that it is not their place to do this because they are not the landlord.

For the past two months they have gone ahead and not paid the full rent, they claim that the Citizens Advice Bureau told them this was justified. If they do this for a further month, they will be 2 months in arrears (because they are already in arrears).

The tenancy of the apartment is not due to expire until September this year and I have no intention of starting legal proceedings against the top floor tenant.

Are the tenants of the maisonette justified in withholding the rent and could they counterclaim against me if I serve notice for rent arrears?

Your advice would be greatly appreciated.

My view is that your tenants are not entitled to withhold rent for this.

There is no way, realistically, you can control what a tenant does once she is living in your flat, and there is a general rules which says that one person cannot be held liable for what another person does.

Your suggestion that they speak to the tenant direct is the best option – after all if the young lady was the flat owner that is what they would do.  Why should they do any different just because she is a tenant?

However it is not all plain sailing.

So far as evicting your tenants are concerned (because of their failure to pay rent), you cannot use the straightforward section 21 procedure until September and if you use the mandatory rent arrears ground, no doubt your tenants will put in a defence and counterclaim.

How this goes will depend on what view the Judge takes of it at the initial hearing.  I would hope that he would dismiss it, saying that they cannot deduct rent on the basis of something which is not your fault.  However another Judge may decide that the matter ought to be investigated and list the case for a full hearing.

This would be very bad news for you as it will delay the claim for possession and would complicate the case and make it more expensive. It would be a good idea to have representation at the initial hearing therefore to try to avoid this happening.

I should also mention that there is a very old legal doctrine known as the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher where a land owner is held liable when something ‘escapes’ from land and causes damage.

It is usually used for things like pollution, but it is arguable that it could be used for the ‘escape’ of noise.  I discuss this in this post here.

I personally don’t think this argument would (or should) be accepted by a Judge for a bit of loud music played late at night, but I thought I ought to mention it.

Has anyone else had any experience of this situation?

Tenant prosecutes Lambeth Council over damp and mouldy flat

damp

Tenants whose flats suffer from damp and mould can sometimes prosecute their landords for compensation if the properties are a statutory nuisanceContinue Reading

Noisy neighbour loses her equipment

Cartoon by Wil

Noisy neighbour Karla Knuth gets fined at Plymouth Magistrates Court and her equipment is forfeited. Continue Reading



The Landlord Law Blog from Tessa Shepperson

Tessa is an English lawyer specialising in residential landlord and tenant law.


Legal Services

Legal services are provided via Tessa's online service Landlord Law. Some advice services are provided by Tessa, other legal services are provided by specialist housing firm Anthony Gold.


Disclaimer

The purpose of this blog is to provide information, comment and discussion. Although Tessa, or guest bloggers, may from time to time, give helpful comments to readers' questions, these can only be based on the information given by the reader in his or her comment, which may not contain all material facts. Any comments or suggestions provided by Tessa or any guest bloggers should not therefore be relied upon as a substitute for legal advice from a qualified lawyer regarding any actual legal issue or dispute.


Nothing on this website should be construed as legal advice or perceived as creating a solicitor-client relationship (apart from the Fast Track block clinic service - so far as the questioners only are concerned).


Guest bloggers

Please note that any opinion expressed by a guest blogger is his or hers alone, and does not necessarily reflect the views of Tessa Shepperson, or the other writers on this blog.


Other websites from Tessa

Lodger Landlord | School for Landlords | Google+ | Your Law Store | Google | Landlord Law facebook page | Tenancy Agreements Manual | How to Evict Your Tenant website | the Which Tenancy Agreement Guide | Landlords Tips | Tenants Tips