A problem practically all landlords have had.
You provide a property in perfect condition. However, during an inspection visit, or maybe once the tenants have vacated, you find items that need repair.
What are your rights to charge the cost of this to your tenants?
The Tenant Fees Act 2019
Many landlords will remember the introduction of this act, and how procedures and tenancy agreements had to be amended to take account of it.
The government has recently updated its guidance which landlords need to be aware of. We will be looking at some (although not all) of the points raised in this guidance. Note that this post applies to England only.
The difference between a fee and damages
Landlords, and indeed agents and tenants, often confuse these.
Damages
Landlords can claim damages if the tenant breaches the tenancy agreement in some way, which causes loss to the landlord.
Fees
These are where specific sums of money are imposed on tenants for a service, administration or a specified event, regardless of their behaviour. Most fees are illegal under the Tenant Fees Act.
There are two exceptions:
- Losing keys – where you can claim costs reasonably incurred by you to replace the lost keys, or
- Paying rent late – where (subject to the rules set out in the Act) you can claim interest at 3% above bank base rate.
Cleaning costs
The classic example that explains the difference between a fee and damages is cleaning.
If the tenancy agreement imposes a set fee which tenants have to pay towards cleaning, whether or not the property is left dirty, this is illegal and unenforceable under the Act.
However, if the landlord can prove that the property was clean when let to the tenants but found to be dirty when they leave, then (assuming their tenancy agreement provides for the property to be kept clean) the landlord can charge the tenant the reasonable cost of cleaning to put it back in the condition it was when the tenants moved in.
In most cases, professional cleaning costs will be allowed subject to the production of a receipted invoice.
The prohibition against claiming for fair wear and tear does not apply to cleaning where a property has been vacated and left in a dirty condition.
Note, though, that you cannot require tenants to pay a separate fee for routine cleaning during the tenancy. If you want to employ a cleaner (which may be a good idea for HMO properties), you need to ensure that the rent is sufficient to cover the cost of this.
When can you claim damages?
In most cases, you will be claiming the cost from the tenant’s deposit, after they have vacated the property. This is after all what the deposit is for.
Subject to agreement or successful resolution through the deposit scheme’s dispute procedure (or maybe the Courts) if challenged.
However, there are times when it will be appropriate for you to claim during the tenancy.
The government guidance gives the example of a broken window. Provided the repair cannot reasonably wait until the end of the tenancy and the tenant is responsible for the damage.
How can you tell if the tenant is responsible?
Comparing the condition at the start of the tenancy, or your last inspection, will help.
However, you also need evidence that the damage resulted from a breach of the tenant’s obligations, rather than fair wear and tear, a defect or some other cause for which the tenant is not responsible.
The guidance suggests that the relevant sum either be recovered in agreement with the tenants or through legal proceedings.
If you decide to leave it and deduct it from the deposit at the end of the tenancy, make sure you keep evidence of the cost and the fact that the damage was caused by the tenants.
Some practical tips
As usual with landlording today, it is imperative that you carry out regular inspections (so you can pick up on problems) and keep detailed records (so you can prove any claims made).
So, if you find damage:
- Identify the obligation the tenant has breached. What does your tenancy agreement say?
- Keep evidence of the condition before and afterwards. In most cases, this will mean your agreed inventory from the start of the tenancy and either your inspection report or the checkout report when the tenant vacates
- Explain how the tenant caused the loss.
- Provide a clear calculation and supporting documents. For example, for damage to items in the property, ‘betterment’ will apply, meaning that you cannot have ‘new lamps for old’. Your records should include receipts for all items purchased for the property and estimates and receipted invoices for any work done or which needs doing.
- Invite the tenant’s response before escalating a disputed claim. Hopefully you will be able to reach an amicable agreement. If this proves difficult and particularly if there is a large sum involved, you may want to try mediation before issuing any court proceedings.
And finally
One of the central points of the Tenants Fees Act was to make automatic charges to tenants illegal. So agents can no longer charge tenants for tenancy agreements, management fees, letters sent to them (eg regarding outstanding rent) or automatic cleaning costs.
However, the Act does not remove the right for a landlord to make a claim for compensation if the tenant has breached the terms of the tenancy agreement and caused the landlord to suffer loss.
Provided, of course, that the landlord is able to prove this.
Leave a Reply